As we dive into Q2 of 2025, the gaming industry has already delivered some incredible titles, ranging from indie surprises to blockbuster sequels. According to Metacritic, the gold standard for review aggregation, several games have soared past the 90 mark, earning “universal acclaim” and securing their spots among the best-reviewed games of the year (so far).

Whether you’re looking for deep narrative adventures, challenging puzzles, or innovative co-op gameplay, this list highlights the highest-scoring games of 2025 based on critical reviews available as of April.

1. Blue Prince (Metascore: 92)

Genre: Indie, Roguelike Puzzle
Developer: Dogubomb
Platform: PC (with console ports planned)

Leading the pack is the surprise indie hit Blue Prince, a roguelike puzzle game that has captured the attention of critics with its original design, eerie atmosphere, and layered gameplay mechanics. Players explore a mysterious, shifting mansion where no two rooms are the same, making every run feel fresh and unpredictable.

Praised for its creativity and immersive style, Blue Prince holds the highest Metacritic score of 2025 so far, earning a 92 and the coveted “universal acclaim” badge.

2. The Talos Principle: Reawakened (Metascore: 91)

Genre: Puzzle Adventure
Developer: Croteam
Platform: PC, PS5, Xbox Series X/S

The sequel to the critically acclaimed philosophical puzzler, The Talos Principle: Reawakened, continues its legacy with even more intricate puzzles, stunning visuals, and existential themes. Critics have highlighted the game’s thought-provoking narrative and mechanically rich puzzles as standout elements.

Its score of 91 places it right behind Blue Prince and cements its place as one of the most intellectually engaging games of the year.

3. Kingdom Come: Deliverance II (Metascore: 91)

Genre: Historical RPG
Developer: Warhorse Studios
Platform: PC, PS5, Xbox Series X/S

Kingdom Come: Deliverance II has exceeded expectations with its deep storytelling, historical accuracy, and expansive open world. The sequel refines everything from the first game and adds a more fluid combat system, better AI, and rich side content.

Its commitment to realism and authenticity has earned it strong praise, and a Metacritic score of 91 makes it one of the year’s most successful RPGs to date.

4. Split Fiction (Metascore: 90)

Genre: Co-op Adventure
Developer: Hazelight Studios
Platform: PC, PS5, Xbox Series X/S

From the creators of It Takes Two, Split Fiction delivers a new kind of co-op narrative experience. With a blend of cinematic storytelling, dynamic puzzles, and character-driven gameplay, it’s been hailed as another masterpiece from Hazelight.

Its focus on emotional depth and tight two-player mechanics helped it secure a 90 on Metacritic, making it a must-play for fans of shared adventures.

5. Monster Hunter Wilds (Metascore: 89)

Genre: Action RPG
Developer: Capcom
Platform: PS5, Xbox Series X/S, PC

Monster Hunter Wilds builds on the success of Monster Hunter: World, introducing new ecosystem-based challenges, weapon evolutions, and fluid multiplayer systems. It’s been praised for its ambition and world-building, though some reviews mention its steep learning curve.

Its Metascore of 89 puts it just shy of the top 3, but it remains one of the most highly anticipated and praised AAA titles of the year.

Other High-Scoring Titles in 2025

• Keep Driving (Metascore: 89) – A stylish driving sim with meditative, narrative-driven design.
• Expelled! (Metascore: 86) – A chaotic, humor-filled party game with clever mechanics.
• Citizen Sleeper 2: Starward Vector (Metascore: 86) – A beautifully written narrative RPG with deep world-building.
• Ender Magnolia: Bloom in the Mist (Metascore: 85) – A gorgeous Metroidvania with haunting art and fluid combat.
• Two Point Museum (Metascore: 85) – The spiritual successor to Two Point Hospital, now set in a quirky museum management sim.

Closing Thoughts

2025 is already shaping up to be a memorable year in gaming, especially for fans of innovative indie titles, rich RPGs, and smartly designed co-op experiences. Whether you’re planning your next playthrough or just love tracking the year’s best games, these top-rated titles are well worth your time.

As review aggregations continue to update, some rankings may shift, but Blue Prince, The Talos Principle: Reawakened, and Kingdom Come: Deliverance II sit proudly at the top.

🎮 Which one are you playing next?

Let us know in the comments, or better yet, build your own top 5 list. For now, keep an eye on these standout titles as 2025 unfolds with even more releases to come!